In This Moment: A Rabbi's Notebook
A bobcat meandered through my backyard today. You can see it above, somewhat camoflaged by the leaves. It’s a largely solitary animal, unlike we humans, who tend to travel in packs - or as we call them, tribes.
In Hebrew the word tribe is shevet and it has within it the verb shev – settle. C’mon in. Set a spell. Put your feet up. That’s what a tribe should be – a family writ large. The word shevet also means a shepherd’s staff. We see it in the 23rd Psalm:
שִׁבְטְךָ וּמִשְׁעַנְתֶּךָ, הֵמָּה יְנַחֲמֻנִי. Your rod and your staff they comfort me
It’s about the comfort of the collective, the passion of peoplehood and faith in a shepherd who will keep us together and not lead us down the wrong path.
But now “tribe” has become a dirty word.
Jim Mattis wrote in his memoir:
“What concerns me most as a military man is not our external adversaries; it is our internal divisiveness. We are dividing into hostile tribes cheering against each other, fueled by emotion and a mutual disdain that jeopardizes our future, instead of rediscovering our common ground and finding solutions. All Americans need to recognize that our democracy is an experiment—and one that can be reversed…. Tribalism must not be allowed to destroy our experiment.”
For Jews, tribalism has been problematic since the very beginning of Israelite nationhood, right up until, literally, today. And tribal leaders have compounded the problem by exacerbating intertribal tensions, pitting groups against each other to preserve their power and distract people from their corruption. It’s a tale as old as time - and as current as, well, the current issue of Time.
“Was there, ever, a people whose leaders were as truly their enemies as this one?” asked Ernest Hemingway in For Whom the Bell Tolls. Historian/ Journalist Amotz Asa-El suggests that there is such a people, the Jewish people, and in his captivating book, The Jewish March of Folly, just out in English but originally published in Hebrew in 2019, which feels like many lifetimes - and marches of folly - ago, he sets out to prove it.
It’s based on Barbara Tuchman’s 1980’s best seller, The March of Folly: From Troy to Vietnam, which investigated why nations so often pursue policies that undermine their own self-interest. An updated version of that book might just include every policy choice made by the Trump administration, which has been a parade of folly unto itself. The fact that we’ve made measles great again and boosted Iran into a great power is just a sampling of the horrible choices that have been made.
Asa-El’s book covers all of Jewish history, going back to the biblical kingdoms of Judah and Israel, and even before that, to the intertribal conflicts described in the books of Judges and Samuel. I’d almost forgotten just how many civil wars sprung up in those first centuries after the settlement of the Promised Land. One tribe, Dan, even faced a sort of ethnic cleansing, evicted from its territory (near what is now Tel Aviv) by its bullying fellow tribe of Judah and chased to the northernmost hinterlands bordering Lebanon. That’s why biblical maps of the tribes often locate Dan in two places.
And then there were the many bad choices made during the post-biblical period when Jews fought for positioning among their big-power rivals and rulers, even - in perhaps the all-time dumbest move - inviting Rome to take over the country just to keep bickering Jewish siblings apart. Asa-El describes it:
On one side stood Queen Salome’s son, high priest Johanan Hyrcanus and on the other side stood his brother Judah Aristobulus, the Judean army’s commander. Jericho, the first town Israel conquered after entering the Promised Land, would now see a pair of Jewish armies storm one another, each led by a Jewish prince. Worse, one of the brothers offered pieces of land to his foreign allies; then climbed with them to Jerusalem, and then laid siege to the temple, where his brothers loyalists were entrenched. And then, with the Judean military exposed and politically naked, the Romans arrived (p.193).
This occurred in 63 BCE, and after that, Jews were never fully independent on their own land until the establishment of the State of Israel 1948.
Asa-El makes none-too-subtle allusions to contemporary Israel in his book. But not even the folly of inviting the Roman conquerors into Jerusalem could match what the leaders of the opposition parties seem bent on doing right now - grabbing defeat from the jaws of victory by failing to consummate a new government, each for their own petty, tribal reasons.
The idiocy of what Trump is doing right now in resurrecting the corpse of a defeated Vladimir Putin1 is being matched by these Israeli leaders allowing the defeated Benjamin Netanyahu to hang around just long enough to find himself back at the helm for yet another term, one that could well be fatal to Israeli democracy, its economy, its relations with America and its very existence. I still believe an opposition government will be formed - because there is no alternative and Gadi Eisenkot has committed to putting forward a coalition before he loses the mandate in a few weeks, even if it has to be a minority government that would depend on tacit support of the Arab parties. But right now, we’ve got a mess that, if it weren’t so terrifying, would be comical. Here’s how Mideast expert David Makovsky explains this utter stupidity in layman’s language:
While this jockeying keeps happening, Bibi is trying desperately to ignite a new conflagration in Iran, even conspiring with Mossad to going over the head of his own armed forces (the IDF has been thwarting his aggressive intents since before the election). But for some reason, he can’t convince Trump to come out and play this time. And today, a mosque was set aflame in Northern Israel2 and Jewish supremacists are agitating everywhere. There is not a minute to lose.
No one believes that this delay is happening. All the arguments being given by the oppo leaders don’t hold water. Gadi Eisenkot knows that this looks really bad, and Naftali Bennett, who knows American culture as well as Bibi, has got to understand that a failure to form a Bibi-free government would be catastrophic.
On Twitter, the pundits are panicking.

Maybe Lapid’s message is that (wink, wink) there’s a plan in place and all this is an overreaction. But the seriousness of the moment demands such an overreaction. 3
In his book, Asa-El sees tribalism as “nationhood’s most potent enemy,” and indeed, over and over again we have seen unity sacrificed at the altar of the tribe. Back in the Bible, with the tribe of Dan gone from the coastal plain, Judah trained its sights on Benjamin, a smaller tribe that had been spreading southwest to the fertile plain of Lydda. This resulted in increased tension, especially given the burn of having the first Israelite king, Saul hailing from Benjamin. Ultimately, Judah, which had devoured Simeon and banished Dan as if they were Venezuela and Greenland, subjugated Benjamin and replaced King Saul with their own favorite son David, who then conveniently set out to unite all the tribes. Bullies always claim to be unifiers. “Come together, right now…OVER ME.”
David succeeded by moving the capital from Judean Hebron to a neutral site in between the northern and southern tribes (much like Washington DC), Jerusalem, which had been in the neutral territory of Benjamin until Judah absorbed it.4 Asa-El calls Judah’s endeavor an effort “to realize the very cause it had just debilitated and would continue to subvert for centuries, with fateful results.”
For Bibi to be calling for unity now, after all he has done to alienate so many, including virtually the entire Democratic party, is laughable.
America has had its tribes too. North and South, Red States and Blue States. But the map has suddenly been wiped clean, reset like every internet router that has shut down over the past week. Red Texas is no longer red, but neither is it really blue. What it is, is different, and we now have an almost unprecedented opportunity to reinvent our country and redefine what it means to be an American - in a manner that goes beyond tribal identity. If we can accomplish that, a true realignment will be at hand. No need to reach across the aisle. Why not just fill the empty space by putting down a few more chairs?
Tribalism doesn’t have to be divisive. A few years ago, Israel’s past president Ruby Rivlin gave a famous speech about Israel’s Four Tribes, which for him include secular Jews, national religious Orthodox Jews, ultra-Orthodox Haredi Jews, and Arabs
See below how an Israeli artist depicted the current 12 Tribes of Israel (click for website): Ultra-Orthodox, Israeli Arabs, Ashkenazi, Mizrahim, settlers, American Jews, Ethiopians, Russians, LGBTQ, the young, the veterans and refugees. While each tribe is distinct, the colors and designs produce a collective harmony that is far greater than the sum of the parts.5
Note that Arabs are part of the tribal scheme here. So why should they not be welcomed into Israel’s governing coalition, especially given how at least one of their parties, Ra’am, is willing to compromise to the nth degree in order to be acceptable?
Asa-El’s book initially ended optimistically and was a bestseller in Israel, celebrated by Prime Minister Bennett, who distributed it to his ministers, and Rivlin - the Tribe Guy - himself celebrated it. Then came Israel’s far right government, the Judicial Coup, October 7 and the wars. His epilogue is much less hopeful, but neither is it hopeless, as you can see in this excerpt:
So the question is, can the tribes, all the tribes, come together to forge a common home, and a transformed home, in Israel, in America, in the world.
The lesson learned from biblical times is that tribalism cannot be about ethnicity, or blood and soil, but about embracing those who are beyond the boundaries of the tribe and welcoming them in.
“Never again,” Jews everywhere must declare, will racist vitriol be allowed to infect the Jewish soul. As Americans, we need to declare it too.
As we move into the holiday season, let’s make this a year to redefine what it means to be a tribe. There is no “us and them.” There is only “us.” May we treat everyone as an honorary, if not official, Member of the Tribe. We can even invite in the bobcat.
And let it begin today in both America and Israel, with governments of change.
NOTES
Anyone miss the greatest symbolic moment of the Ukraine War, the blowing up of the Kirch Bridge connecting Russia and Crimea? Well, here it is, for your viewing pleasure.
Click to see story in Times of Israel













