In This Moment: A Rabbi's Notebook
A potpourri of goodies today to catch us up after a busy fortnight…Don’t try to consume all of this in one sitting. It’s like a good lentil stew. It stays with you for a while…
We’re enjoying some crisp midfall weather here on the Connecticut shoreline. A chance to catch up on a few crunchy post-mortems, now that the leaves have fallen, the guarded elation has given way to harsh realities that remain and the autocrats have been left to their ugly, false conspiracy theories.
So which is worse, being accused of complicity to genocide by some leftist firebrands or of backstabbing and treason by the President of the United States?
The answer is that both are unspeakably bad and must be called out, continuously and courageously, by Jewish organizations and individuals. There’s no picking your poison here. All poison is toxic.
We face a pincer movement of diametrically different antisemitic strands zeroing in on a common target, if not common cause.
Democrats increasingly blame Jews for genocide. It’s become the password for entry into the speakeasy of 2028 politics, and it’s not just the far left anymore. The accusation is antisemitic and a modern blood libel that diminishes the Holocaust. And what more proof do we need that it’s directed against Jews, not merely Israel. than the recent boycott of Philly Jewish-owned restaurants? What, are they committing genocide with gefilte fish? Murdering with matzo balls? Attacking Jewish delis for Israeli actions is like protesting globalism by boycotting the International House of Pancakes.
Meanwhile, like the good wannabee fascists they are, Trump Republicans are coalescing around Vance’s and Trump’s assertions that Jews stabbed them in the back by manipulating America into the Iran War and by not voting for Republicans “despite all Trump has done for us.”
So, are we genocidal or backstabbers - or simply genocidal backstabbers?
The MAGA strain of this disease has the greatest immediate potential to harm American Jews. And it is metastasizing fast. Following the influential screeds of Tucker Carlson that “Israel dragged us into war,” Trump and Vance are already blaming Israel for the Iran war and subsequent defeat, even though they have yet to admit it was a defeat, and Trump has blamed Jews, many times, for failing to support him in elections or for appreciating his “help” in combating antisemitism on college campuses (while decimating higher education and free speech).
Trump did it again in his recent interview with Hugh Hewitt, acting incredulous about enduring Jewish support for Democrrats, including the oft-demonized Abdul el-Sayed in Michigan. “It’s a tough group to get,” he said, which was at least a little milder than prior comments about Jews needing to get their heads examined for continuing to support the Dems.
And indeed, a recent poll confirms that 72 percent of Jews voted Democratic in the midterms,1 virtually unchanged from 2024, including in Michigan.
Keep an eye out for Trump to take the inevitable next step. The guy who used to have Hitler’s speeches at bedside has shown that he is well schooled in the stab-in-the-back theory that targeted Jews a century ago. His peeps have used it before, against various targets following the 2020 race, and they are bound to use it again this year, on Jews and Israel. With Vance and Tucker Carlson leading the way, Trump is ready and eager to chime in.
Propaganda picture that blames the German loss on WW1 on the Jews. Rich Jews are portrayed as the instruments of “betrayal” by the German government. (Public domain - Anne Frank House website)
Long ago, after another ill-fated war that dragged the world into an economic morass, German leaders decided that the Jews would be a convenient group to blame. The blood had not yet completely dried along the trenches of Verdun and the Somme, the ink had barely dried on the Treaty of Versailles, and the Nazis weren’t even yet a blip on the radar, when this theory began to bubble up, led by Field Marshal Von Hindenberg, among others.2
But Hitler caught on quickly and this theory became, according to one scholar, “the ideological cement of his dictatorship.”
Simultaneously, the Jews could be portrayed both as rich capitalists undermining patriotic German forces and conniving communists fomenting revolts back home, further draining morale at the front. This ostensibly forced the German military to seek a premature armistice, even though they had, in their own minds, not been beaten. Add to that a critique that Zionism was also at fault, leading Jews to betray Germany out of a double loyalty to a country not yet born.3
So now what do we have here in America? Watch Trump and Vance continue to distance themselves from Israel, heaping blame on them for GOP losses. And watch your back.
Meanwhile…
Netanyahu’s scheme to steal the Israeli election is exposed in Israeli media. WATCH THIS REPORT FROM ISRAEL’S TOP INVESTIGATIVE NEWS PROGRAM, BROADCAST LAST NIGHT.
Watch the subtitled video above and read the report from Israel’s channel 12 (translated below by Google) to grasp what is now unfolding in Israel. Fortunately, they still have a (mostly) free press, even though - like here - the justice and intelligence arms have been corrupted and co-opted by the autocratic leader. The plot we are seeing unfold here makes Watergate seem like a Girl Scout cookie sale. It’s election subversion, voter suppression and outright slander against an entire community and then throw in some racism and character assassination - it’s a pretty neat trick. It is now clear that Bibi plotted to frame the Arab parties and sway the elections - and while he nearly succeeded, the opposition has it within their power right now to drive him from power. Now more than ever, the Prime Minister has become the greatest existential threat to Israeli democracy.4
As Gadi Eisenkot proclaimed in today’s headline, he’s got to go. Today.
Headline below:
Eisenkot: It is Forbidden for Netanyahu to Remain at the Head of the Government Even for One More Minute!”
Meanwhile…
Below is the audio of my sermon from last Shabbat, looking at Esau selling the birthright for a bowl of soup in the context of gratification delayed and persistence rewarded for long suffering groups in the midterms.
Excerpts from the sermon, delivered at Temple Beth Tikva, Madison.
“…And so, for a bowl of soup, Jacob buys the birthright (Genesis 25) , but he never buys into Esau’s impulsiveness. And one generation later, neither does his son Joseph, who convinces the entire nation of Egypt to store their grain for seven years, which assures them of a future – which keeps them from dying.
Delayed gratification is the key to staving off death.
…Here’s some juicy – or soupy - symbolism. There’s something about the redness of that pottage that attracts Esau. He uses the word twice – RED, RED – or deep red. Red like Esau himself, whose alternate name was Edom, Red. Deep red… like Mississippi and South Carolina – or at least until last week.
In the midrash, Esau doesn’t just eat the pottage. He opens his mouth like a camel and makes Jacob pour it in. He can’t even wait for the invention of the spoon! He doesn’t even know what’s in the soup when he starts to eat. Just that it’s red.”
“And when you think of the fate of that red, red person Esau, who was unable to wait, when you think of other people of color who had to delay gratification for years, decades, centuries. Think of the Blacks of Mississippi, the Hispanics of South Texas, the Haitians of Springfield, Ohio, the Native Americans of New Mexico and Indigenous Yupik of Alaska, the openly LGBTQ of New Hampshire, the physically challenged of Iowa, the Black women of Georgia, and yes, the Arab voters of Lod, Ramla and Sachnin in Israel. All found a degree of redemption over the past few weeks. All of them saw the arc of history start to bend toward justice. All of them had the patience to wait and the understanding that gratification would not be instant - and the courage to act decisively when the time was right.”

Finally, see my post-election conversation with Israel expert Marc Schulman
Key findings from the national survey include:
72% of Jewish voters supported Democratic congressional candidates, compared with 24% who backed Republicans, continuing the community’s longstanding Democratic voting patterns.
76% disapprove of President Donald Trump’s job performance, including 74% who strongly disapprove.
Democracy and the economy were the leading electoral concerns. Forty-four percent identified the future of democracy as one of their two most important voting issues, followed by the cost of living and economy at 34%. Israel was selected by 14%.
76% support sanctions against violent West Bank settlers, and an identical percentage support sanctions against Israeli government ministers who aid and abet settler violence. Fifty-nine percent support sanctions against businesses and individuals involved in building or financing West Bank settlements.
66% believe AIPAC’s campaign spending against candidates who criticize Israel increases antisemitism in the United States. Separately, 39% said support from an AIPAC super PAC makes them less likely to support a candidate, compared with 13% who said more likely.
80% believe Israel’s actions in Gaza and the West Bank increase antisemitism in the United States. Sixty percent believe Jewish organizations that condemn harsh criticism of Israel as antisemitic are exploiting concerns about antisemitism to defend unpopular Israeli government policies.
From the Holocaust Encyclopedia
A version of the stab-in-the-back myth was publicized in 1922 by the antisemitic Nazi theorist Alfred Rosenberg in his primary contribution to Nazi theory on Zionism, Der Staatsfeindliche Zionismus (Zionism, the Enemy of the State). Rosenberg accused German Zionists of working for a German defeat and supporting Britain and the implementation of the Balfour Declaration. (see Wikipedia, including the note below)























No comments:
Post a Comment